Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Explaining Jeremy Lin's Early, Surprising Success

Boulware Reclaims Spot in Starting Lineup -- Also: Is the Marshall Plan Suspect?

Sando reports that strong safety Michael Boulware has regained his starting job, replacing Jordan Babineaux.

Boulware was benched in October after a shaky series of games, culminating in the home loss to the Vikings. Babineaux missed some crucial tackles in last weekend's still inexplicable loss to the 49ers.

I'd like to go back a few days to pick up on another item that at least partially addresses one question I've been silently asking myself since I renounced ownership of my eternal soul. (Namely, the loss in Arizona.)

That question was this: Why has nobody -- in public at least -- suggested that Seahawks defensive coordinator John Marshall bear some culpability in this season's defensive failures? And should he?

I've wrestled with this question a little bit, only because the stronger visual evidence showed a bunch of missed tackles, broken patterns, blown assignments, and a couple untied shoelaces. But could some of this be about a game plan that comes up a bit short?

Ryan Davis of Scout.Com poses the question himself, and has stats. He also reviews whether benching Boulware at all was a good idea to begin with. (Here's a hint: No.)

Comment 4 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Good.
I've been itching to see Boulware back for a while now. I was slightly in favor of the benching back in the day, but after seeing Babineaux play (wasn't he supposed to cover the pass?) I'm grateful to have somebody who can (most of the time) tackle.
Hey, if you didn't want to get your legs broken, pal, you never should have tried to do your job in the first place.

by Phil Hatzenbuehler on Dec 20, 2006 4:25 PM PST reply actions  

Babs can cover the pass alright
but teams have been killing us with there ground game, which I think is worse actually  
"I got to fulfill every defender's dream of punching Tom Nalen in the head" - Chuck Darby

by Scruffy Lefty on Dec 20, 2006 5:34 PM PST reply actions  

Decent writer; Abusive use of stats
First, Marshall made the mistake of forcing Grossman to pass? Zuh?
Assuming for a second that Marshall dictated Chicago's game-planning, who on earth wouldn't have preferred the inexperienced and not very good Grossman throwing the ball to one of the league's top rushing attacks running roughshod?

But what I really find galling is that he lists 6 games pre-benching, 7 games post benching, accounts for no other variables like, I don't know, the health of our D-Line or the ability of our opponent, and then when he doesn't get the results he wants he simply removes a couple games for rather spurious reasons.

This is abusive use of statistics at its finest. Ryan Davis clearly already had a conclusion he wanted to reach before starting this article, and then simply found something that (kind of) backed up his opinion.

Now, do I think that benching Boulware was a bad idea? Yes. You don't a bench a young player who has shown flashes of brilliance for a journeyman not likely to be on your roster next year. At the very least we would have a better understanding of what we have with Boulware, because, honestly, we already knew the dross we had with Babineaux.

This stinks to me of a punishment move by Marshall. An attempt to correct Boulware that got out of hand and has likely stunted his growth. After two seasons the jury is still at the motel when it comes to our young Defensive Coordinator. Our recent struggles absolutely should not be valued more than the awesome job he did last year.

by John Morgan on Dec 20, 2006 5:47 PM PST reply actions  

I agree
John Marshall came in last year with a fresh, crisp breeze, turning a talented but never-fearsome defense into a pretty potent force.  The defense was the difference last season, it was their power their made us 13-3, in my opinion (well, that an the best offensive line in football).

But this year...what can you say?  Obviously Marshall has the ability, he created saavy gameplans last year that really paid off for us.  It's not a lack of talent.  But something has sure switched around, because this year I have no hope for us being able to stop anyone.  

I'm wondering if it's possible that Marshall and Rhodes are battling each other for control of the defense?  I mean, Rhodes is still attached in an "advisory" capacity, right?  He's a gung-ho ballbuster, though.  I can't see him sitting back at all....

Whatever the reason, I'm glad to see Boulware get back out there, just for something new if nothing else.  God, all I want for Christmas is some consistent pressure on the opposing QB....and a Wii.....

by jimmimoose on Dec 20, 2006 6:18 PM PST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

SEA!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Avatar_small
The Official Field Gulls OT Thread - In Which We Gush About Our Favorite TV Shows

Recent FanPosts

Photo_on_2011-10-14_at_23
Jim Harbaugh Vs. Pete Carroll
Small
Nation Wide Mock Draft
Small
Could Dre Kirkpatrick be the key to our 2012 draft?
Einstein_www-txt2pic-com_small
Seahawks QB Situation: Not a Defense for Tarvaris Jackson
Small
Team Needs - The National Perception of Seattle
Small
2012 Mock Draft, Version 1.0
Walshrun_small
Super Bowl XLVI Reaction: New England Patriots
Small
My Friend has a Friend who works for Nike...
208114_505637750968_23709013_30160241_9483_n_small
GM John Schneider On The Ideal QB
Bodypaint_small
Delocated ad

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor/Lead Writer

284430_601240951600_44900771_32958650_2317286_n_small Danny Kelly

Staff Writers/Editors

Screen_shot_2011-01-05_at_9 Scruffy Lefty

Small BrianL

Avatar_small Benne

Olympiabeer_small Tyler Jorgensen

Hatersgonnahate_small Thomas Beekers

Profilepic_small DJ C-Raig

897267_o_small Kenneth Arthur

Halloween_mobster_small Jacson Bevens

Photo__1__small Charlie Todaro

Staff Writers

Small Joshua Kasparek

Mail Matt Erickson

Davis_small Davis Hsu

Profile2_small Rob Staton

208114_505637750968_23709013_30160241_9483_n_small Scott Enyeart

Elephant_pink_clothes_small Chris Sully

Seattle_seahawk_white_1600_reasonably_small_small Derek Stephens

Osprey1_small Ben Harbaugh

Easleystreet2_small ChadDavis45

Bu_fb_2_small Daniel Hill