Field Gulls: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: A Look Back: Steelers-Chargers 2008 Regular Season MatchUp Bar-right-arrows



Opinion on the 1st Round

I like the thought of having a talented tight end, but generally I don't usually see this as such a need position if there is any other high-caliber player on the board. Personally, I'm a fan of running backs, and love to see an exciting, consistent ground game. Part of me doesn't believe our backs, even with Morris will be able to provide that.

If there is a talented Safety, or an upper tier offensive linemen, then yeah I could see an easy case made for that. But I feel that the players we have on our line this year are more built for success now than our running back depth chart is. Our offense never was consistent running the ball, and the more I look back on it I firmly believe we had no belief that it would be successful. Limited carries, no matter how lackluster the talent, will  most likely never get the job done.

If Stewart or Mendenhall are on the board, I go for them. A nice sized, complete, hard running back is something we have missed. If they are gone, and the talent on the board is leaning safety or wide receiver, then I go there. Fred Davis to me, shouldn't even be one of our first thoughts If he's not able to immediately improve our offense on multiple levels.

0 recs | Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

well
I always thought in the first round, if thre's a valuable lineman available, you should take them, because that is the premium position. It's where the game is won and lost. So I think Offensive line in this draft, but I'd be intrigued in someone like Calais Campbell, even though DE isn't a glaring need. Like they say, you can't coach size, 6'8" guys don't grow on trees.

by enderdace on Feb 20, 2008 1:32 AM PST   0 recs

no, 6'8" guys do not grow on trees
But if you covered them in leaves and bark they'd look like one.

Anyway, the point is, size is overrated. Steve Smith is a top wideout in the league, Warrick Dunn got it done for years, Maurice Jones-Drew, etc. Dwight Freeney is too light, Tapp is too short, Drew Brees is too short, and Bob Sanders is too small. Picking someone for size alone is what gets Sonics in trouble every year, save Durant.

You pick based on production.

Celebrated my 20th birthday on 02/05/2006. Not a good day.

by abender20 on Feb 20, 2008 8:37 AM PST   0 recs

RB or OL for me
I would take a RB or OL, depending on who is left on the board.  I am leaning towards OL.  I have not done any real research, but it seems like running backs can come out of no where and run well if they are following a good line, plus your line protects your QB.  Ryan Grant, Earnest Graham, Najeh Davenport, and Kenton Keith all seemed to do pretty good when they came in to replace an injured player, and all averaged 4 or more yards per attempt.  We have two startes on the OL who are over 34 years old, so we need some youth to replace them when needed.

by germpod on Feb 20, 2008 11:56 AM PST   0 recs

for every 5'8" guy having success
there are ten 6'2" guys doing great things. Then there are about another 500 million undersized who either failed or never even got the opportunity. Not that I was talking about receivers or backs anyway, I was talking specifically about linemen. When it comes to the trenches, having the right size and athleticism gives you a natural advantage... As for the guys in that position you did mention, it's worth remembering with the undersized Freeney and Mathis, the Colts had a pathetic run defense. Also, Tapp is way too short. As far as Calais Campbell is concerned, I did say I was 'intrigued' - not sold. I feel he should have gone back for his senior year. However, assuming he is the kind of player I'd hope he'd be, I'd much rather use a first round pick on a premium player like that rather than a running back who everyone will probably booing five or six years from now. When you're playing on the line, you have a space of about five steps in each direction of yourself to work in and that's pretty much it. Of course you need to have good technique, but if you don't have the right size and athleticism, you just will not have enough leverage to win the battle, it will look like that State Farm ad. You have to have those long arms to reach out, create the leverage, give yourself space to work in. You must have that first step to get off the line. You can teach someone how to use their hands and feet - you can't teach someone how to grow three inches... well, not legally at least.

by enderdace on Feb 20, 2008 4:25 PM PST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Walter Jones, you were the greatest, most dominant player I've ever seen at any position. It's been an honor to be your fan.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Utah's Attorney General suing the BCS?
Front_of_car_small
Should the Hawks go after TJ Houshmandzadeh in Free Agency
Small
Hakeem Nicks Goes Pro
Boomheadshot_small
Adam Schefter reports Rod Marinelli is talking with Seahawks for D Coordinator
Front_of_car_small
11 reasons not to draft Sam Bradford or Tim Tebow
Picofme_small
The Taylor Mays Microsoft Connection
Front_of_car_small
Big School Myth?
Small
Video Review - 2008 Season
Jj_flag_detail1_small
Top 5 Beer Discoveries of 2008
Small
Cover-3: Wild-Card Edition

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Image_114_small Shrug

Jj_flag_detail1_small John Morgan

Graphics Editor

Picture_1_small Scruffy Lefty

Writer

Small Doug Farrar

The Man Behind the Man

Small BrianL

ad

Site Meter