Field Gulls: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: The Boxing Bulletin for Boxing Fans!

When Should You Hold?

"Hmm, Dockett gets to the QB 44% of the time he beats his lineman. This referee has been a little slow to notice my hand placement, and Dockett already has his shoulder by me. The coordinates of the corresponding point are then below a line with slope .81, so I'd better grab that mofo. Why is Matt on the ground holding his knee?" (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

More photos » by Elaine Thompson - AP

"Hmm, Dockett gets to the QB 44% of the time he beats his lineman. This referee has been a little slow to notice my hand placement, and Dockett already has his shoulder by me. The coordinates of the corresponding point are then below a line with slope .81, so I'd better grab that mofo. Why is Matt on the ground holding his knee?" (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)


Probability is neat. Brian Burke, the wizard behind the Advanced NFL Stats studies, strikes again. If you don't know the drill by now (follow the link!), you probably voted "13-14" on the poll yesterday. Also, you should stay away from sharp objects.

Using conditional probabilities based on first quarter game data, Burke shows that holding is actually an advantageous strategy more often than you'd think. The math involved is pretty straightforward, so go read. This boils down to game theory that can't possibly be used in a game situation as the odds of holding detection are not known aquantity. Holding detection involves all sorts of factors, like the egregiousness of the hold and the visibility of the interaction to the corresponding referee. Still, it makes an interesting case study. If you assume that getting beat results in a sack even 30% of the time, it's only worth holding if you the ref will blow the whistle 25% of the time or less. Bump  p(sack | beat) up to 50% and you'd still have to hope the ref swallows his whistle on all but 40% of holds. Now assume your quarterback enjoys holding the ball and DeMarcus Ware is currently on his way by you (let's be honest, you aren't stopping Ware). Take him down.

0 recs  |  Comment 13 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Agreed.

I liked the Billy McMullin one even more, but this one made me chuckle.

by thebyron on Jun 25, 2009 12:52 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Going Wittgenstein

is now added to my daily chatter notebook!

by Bodach on Jun 30, 2009 2:33 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Worried about the jellyfish.
Start posting about the Seahawks »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Jj_flag_detail1_small
Field Gulls Mod-enforced Rules and Standards

Recent FanPosts

Tigeravitar_small
Football Logic: 101
Olympiabeer_small
The Official Fantasy Football Thread – Week 11. The place for fantasy talk, thought, questions and general fantasy ranting.
Small
Post Your Hawk: Week 11
Rainbow_small
Video Preview: Seattle Seahawks at Minnesota Vikings
Small
Putting a bow on the Hutchinson debate for hawk fans
Jj_flag_detail1_small
Off Topic: Best Sequels, Worst Decisions and Plans for 2010
Profilepic_small
Alright, I Officially Hate Adrian Peterson.
Me_at_the_vikings_game_small
Ask the Daily Norseman
Small
The Two 1st-Rounders in 2010
Profilepic_small
Mora's Presser and General Feelings Towards Our HC

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Bleeding Green Nation
Eagles shuffle linebackers again
Big Blue View
Antonio Pierce out indefinitely
Arrowhead Pride
Friday Night Open Thread

Managers

Image_114_small Shrug

Jj_flag_detail1_small John Morgan

Rainbow_small Scruffy Lefty

Authors

Vp081-c_small Christian

Small BrianL

Small abender20

Small Doug Farrar

Dksbtwit_small Johnny Peel (DKSB)