Prologue to the West Coast Defense Explored
I thoroughly enjoyed District 9. It was the funniest movie I've seen this year. As a bloody buddy film successor to Lethal Weapon, I thought it was the best mix of flash, gore and absurdity since Starship Troopers. Both exploit a weighty, thinly conceived and quickly abandoned "message". District 9 challenges race relations. If it did so straight-faced, it would be nauseating and outrageous. The central metaphor of human-alien relations is laughably inappropriate and barely explored. Instead, I think it's meta-satire. It doesn't satirize race relations, but how a safe, unoriginal, exploitative, poorly crafted and tacked on message can impel critics to fight their way out of the theater to be the first to type and publish a slavering review about a film's "genius".
Of course, no one else was laughing.
I would make a horrible film critic. I don't much like movies. I love sports. I love the spontaneity, the complexity and especially the sincerity. However much rubbish the mainstream media wallpapers it with, sports are defiantly true to their own storyline. If one team scores big in the first quarter, that team will most likely win. The progression of a game is logical. The endings often a dragging bore. The unpredictable is truly unpredictable and the satisfaction reaped from the improbable comeback, the upset and the surprise contender is true. Sport is not contrived.
In football, the offense makes the first move. It dictates pace, it gets first movement off the snap and it works from a plan. The offense is creating something. The defense has a plan, but it must change that plan in real-time. It reacts, adjusts, counters and counter-attacks. The defense is the resistance. It doesn't progress. It delays progress. It must overthrow the offense.
Today we look at Seattle's new defense. Yesterday's look at the Seahawks offense was serial. This will be episodic. We don't need the setup, just the punch line. We don't need the doe-eyed alien holding a bizarre-but-cute alien child, we just need the too-earnest human shouting "Go on without me!"
It wasn't a great preseason for defensive execution. Seattle went 4-0, but never dominated. Its defense battled Kyle Orton, Jeff Garcia and Matt Cassel's backup. It didn't overthrow so much as be on the field when the king died. But I'll see what I can find. Jim Mora promised a new and varied playbook. Did we see hints of it in the preseason? Was what we saw in the preseason it?
64 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I'm really hoping Tatupu was going 80% speed
And hasnt lost a step. Other than that, I admit I spent more time watching Reed, Bennett, Walker and the ‘interesting’ players more than I watched the scheme.
It's an extended digression, I know, and it's a habit I won't foster
but like dropping a tackle into coverage, I think such a tactic has occasional utility confusing expectations and disguising the attack.
It's poetic
John, the way you write about football is truly poetic. There is such graphic relevance in your descriptions. This is why I check your blog every day.
Thanks
Or "Needs more cool guns and characters you can identify with"
Brett Favre is the Kenny Powers of football.
I'd be just fine if they never made another one, although I really liked it.
Makes you think if the alien will stay true to his word.
Personally, I think you're giving District 9 way too much credit.
I really, really, really doubt that it has much, if anything, to do with satirizing critics. There’s absolutely no evidence of that in the story, as far as I saw the first time. But a second viewing on DVD (er, Blu Ray) may show me something more.
Starship Troopers, on the other hand, is pure genius, and easily the best “fuck you” to an audience I’ve ever seen since another Verhoeven film – Showgirls.
well i have to watch the movie now....
Occam’s razor might suggest its just laughable due to incompetence. But if Verhoeven could do it, this guy could. I &hearts Starship troopers.
Save your time and money.
It was bad in all the wrong ways. Yet it wasn’t so bad as to become fun. In any way. At all. If there was a message, comment or real attempt at humor I missed it entirely. The audience was routinely insulted by outright explaining the very shallow premise, leaving us no opportunity to think for ourselves and ending by telling us there will most certainly be a District 10. They all but give us the premiere date. Oh wait, this is about the Seahawks….
Great prelude, John. I can’t wait for more.
I'm gonna go calm submissive on your ass.
You're absolutely nuts.
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 9, 2009 6:32 PM PDT up reply actions
Absolutely 100%
You only say that about the ending because they said they make another one if it was successful. If they didn’t said that and ended it like they did now. You would have tons of things to think of for yourself.
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 9, 2009 7:51 PM PDT up reply actions
That wasn't it.
It was when the guy, towards the very end proposed all the silly questions about the aliens’ motives. “Will they come back to declare war, or save their own? Or will they come back at all?” etc… Gee whiz, I don’t know…. Oh boy, please make another one. I can’t stand not knowing.. Please.
Also, I didn’t not know you did that for a living. Very cool. I presumed it was something in that realm, but wasn’t sure.
I'm gonna go calm submissive on your ass.
I thought the "I'll be back in 3 years" business was bogus
It went completely unresolved and was a blatant play for a sequel.
Brett Favre is the Kenny Powers of football.
Yes,
and another issue; the fuel for the space ship can also morph a human into an alien? Okay. If I dab a little unleaded behind my ears, will I (d)evolve into a GM executive?
I'm gonna go calm submissive on your ass.
Obviously you haven't drank any alien jet fuel :)
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 2:55 PM PDT up reply actions
I had some George Dickle not long ago,
tasted like what I imagine alien jet fuel might be.
I'm gonna go calm submissive on your ass.
Yet somehow the alien petrol was a biotech project for the gov't?
Brett Favre is the Kenny Powers of football.
I'm biased to because I was a fan Bloomkamp even before the "Halo" stuff.
He made some of the coolest Nike commercials out there.
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 3:07 PM PDT up reply actions
And am also a HUGE John Carpenter fan.
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 3:08 PM PDT up reply actions
Also remember I shoot documentary style for a living.
So the whole he was giving interview stuff was about the funniest fucking thing I’ve seen in a major motion picture in a long time.
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 9, 2009 7:53 PM PDT up reply actions
Among my many issues with the movie was the the Documentary style wasn't working
And the movie seemed to know it too, because they totally abandoned it about halfway through until bringing it back briefly in the epilogue. Its probably not the best idea to mix a documentary style movie with such an absurd, mentally bankrupt script, but they should have at least stuck with it for the sake of consistency. For a while I wasn’t sure what type of movie District 9 was trying to be.
In the end, I was left feeling that I was either too smart or too stupid to understand the movie, but I wasn’t sure which.
People say they abandoned it - I didn't feel that way.
If I were making a documentary and I had footage of all the events that had transpired I would use them to tell a story and not try to “force” commentary into that.
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 3:04 PM PDT up reply actions
What would be the point of going back to the commentary?
They start by talking about past events – show the past events and then wrap it up in the present.
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 8:31 PM PDT up reply actions
I thought it was fun
It was dumb as hell, but there’s something to be said for rad special effects and buckets of blood.
...no one got this :(
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 2:57 PM PDT up reply actions
I don't understand this comment.
Dumb compared to what? I don’t love it particularly, but if you compare it to other science fiction films I’d say it’s “smarter” than a good 95% of them. I mean, right away, we don’t have Will Smith or Arnie or Bruce Fricking Willis, so automatically it gets points right there.
Special effects were good though. Check out the filmmaker’s stuff on youtube, too.
Yeah, but it's a dumb film masquerading as a smart film
Or the other way around? The clincher is its social-political “cerebral” analogy to apartheid that the critics seem to rave about, and yet every black person in the film is a po dumb thug into spooky religions and exploitation who all get killed in the end in typical dark skinned bad guy fashion. Everybody is a caricature in this film and that makes me think it just had to be done on purpose, but probably not. The only two who show an ounce of humanity (or realistic behavior) are a white man (turning into a bug) and a bug. And even that’s a stretch, but it does go to show that even dumb witless bugs from outer-space are more human then black people. Good anti-apartheid message there.
If I went into this thinking it was just another dumb sci-fi thriller, I would’ve came out thinking I got exactly what I expected. The problem is it tries to pass itself off as something better. It isn’t. I am not actually annoyed at the movie itself, it was above average entertainment, just with all the masterbatory critics who think it has something to say. It doesn’t.
by B.B.Finnegan on Sep 10, 2009 8:55 AM PDT up reply actions
Not it doesn't. Bloomkamp even said he wasn't trying to make a political statement
Just giving a different twist on a typical sci-fi movie.
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 3:02 PM PDT up reply actions
Good post, you said that well
That reminded me of another issue about the movie I had forgotten about. For an alien race possessing technology centuries ahead of our own, they seemed awfully stupid, simple, and barbaric, almost like animals or cavemen. They seemed to care more about eating catfood than conquering Earth or colonizing or whatever the Hell they came to Earth for. These aliens must have been from the “Idiocracy” equivalent of their planet’s future.
I think the idea is that they were the worker bees of their planet
Maybe there was a hive-mind thing or maybe they were enslaved by another group. But they never really addressed this (like a lot of things) and I think that contributed to the empty feeling the movie left me with.
Brett Favre is the Kenny Powers of football.
Lower class workers was the point.
And all the upper classes on the ship died for whatever unexplained reason. I wouldn’t compare them too much to bees, the bugs resemble humans more then anything (intentionally).
Thanks to field gulls, I’ve put way too much thought into this movie already, but I’m beginning to think the whole point of it was to get you to hate humans (the only good human was the one turning into a bug and you almost wish he would so he could play with all the neto guns) and sympathize with the innocent little aliens (there were no bad aliens). Already at the end they had you rooting for the aliens and for all the people to die (black or white alike). This movie will hinge on the sequel. I expect the first half to have much more despiciple acts done by humans, possibly to Wikus’s wife or from her. The flower left sets you up for that. Then the alien returns in a last minute rescue (possibly with the warrior class that knows how to use the weapons), awesome battle ensues, all of humanity is wiped out by their superior weapons with perhaps Wikis becoming their leader and going full bug. Can you imagined if they can accomplish getting the whole audience to cheer on the aliens wiping out all of humanity? They already had you half way there. And then the earth blows up and everyone’s all, “wait, no.” It would be hilarious. One funny head trip to play on the audience.
On the other hand, it could end up just being another two hours of last minute rescues ending on another cliffhanger and part 3 coming to theaters near you next summer.
by B.B.Finnegan on Sep 11, 2009 9:03 AM PDT up reply actions
Oh, I really wish it were a film satirizing film, and satirizing social comentary in film
If i’m wrong and it is, then it’s brilliant.
but I’m really not so sure…but hey, one way or another it’s a joke.
My mom had nothing to do with the brilliance of district 9
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 9, 2009 10:26 PM PDT up reply actions
I absolutely loved District 9 as well
thought it was a great movie all around. I thought it was better than Inglorious Basterds, for sure. 4 more days ‘til Sunday. Can’t wait.
by twocolorcrayon on Sep 10, 2009 12:48 AM PDT up reply actions
Well maybe that's only because she instead had something to do with the retardedness of district 9
by B.B.Finnegan on Sep 10, 2009 9:01 AM PDT up reply actions
MY MOM IS A SAINT
I HAVE NO QUALMS IN STICKING YOU!
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 3:10 PM PDT up reply actions
Fixed
MYYOUR MOM ISA SAINTHOT
I HAVE NO QUALMS IN STICKING it in YOUr mom!
Brett Favre is the Kenny Powers of football.
by ninjasocks on Sep 10, 2009 10:18 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
If that's all we're going to get on defense
I want to see Paul Allen clean house. Ruskell, Mora, and the entire defensive coaching staff needs to be swept out of Seattle if they fail to elevate this defense.
The WCD
Is a riddle wrapped in an enigma. And it cannot be schemed against or stopped. I predict 10 shutouts.
by paul2 on Sep 9, 2009 6:03 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
Listen, and understand.
That WCD is out there. It can’t be bargained with. It can’t be reasoned with. It doesn’t feel pity, or remorse, or fear. And it absolutely will not stop, ever, until you are dead.
by Mind of no mind on Sep 9, 2009 11:10 PM PDT up reply actions
At least we won't have to suffer from Brian Russell any longer.
(!!!)
"Part, fools!
Put up your swords. You know not what you do."
by Fearless Frog on Sep 9, 2009 8:51 PM PDT up reply actions
That move alone should buy Ruskell another 5 years with the team.
Early prospect watch: RB C.J. Spiller, QB Jevan Snead, OT Ciron Black, DT Gerald McCoy, S Eric Berry, DT Ndamukong Suh, CB Ras-I Dowling 6'2, 200, RB Jonathan Dwyer
But how much should we take off for Ruskell adding him in the first place?
Although that could be a wash, we did get two years of funny gifs out of it.
But overall, If there’s one thing I’ve been impressed with Ruskell about, he’s not afraid to cut bait.
by B.B.Finnegan on Sep 10, 2009 8:59 AM PDT up reply actions
Three things
For three years now I’ve been disappointed in the continued disproportionate drafting early on defense at the expense of the offense.
I’d like to see more success with our first round picks. But I was very happy with the Spencer pick, Jennings was an understandable and acceptable reach, and though I’d never heard of Lawrence Jackson, when I read up on him I was happy with it. Sometimes, 5 drafts is enough of a body of work to make some conclusions, but there’s enough contextual factors with the Hawks & Ruskell that the issues with 1st round picks don’t warrant an indictment yet.
Transition tag.
But other than those three things, I’ve been enormously pleased with Ruskell, I’m glad to have him and hope we retain him. I think he’s very good at just about every facet of his job.
by jacobstevens on Sep 11, 2009 2:45 PM PDT up reply actions
I saw District 9 with my Dad a couple weeks ago
It was the most we disagreed on a movie in a long time (I hated it). I’m not sure if I’ve ever seen a more critically acclaimed movie (like 89% on Rotten Tomatoes when we saw it) that did more stupid things with a straight face.
So I’m a bit biased, but when I read the opening paragraph of this article, I couldn’t help but be reminded of this movie review. Maybe JM moonlights as an internet critic?
I just realized
This is the 2nd time in just a few weeks that John Morgan made a reference to his being/not being a film critic. Deep down, he must have a repressed urge to write movie reviews.
John, if you wrote a movie review here I’d probably read it. Some of your best writing is when you gleefully tear stuff apart. I bet it would be a fun read. Heck, most of the comments in this thread were about District 9. You should have a monthly movie review, just to mix things up. : )
As an actual movie critic, and a future film studies professor, I second this.
I’d love to see John’s take on a film every once in a while.
A football game is really just a football movie anyway
And John is a very good football movie critic.
I second that.
Video game critic “Yahtzee” Croshaw has such a fanbase BECAUSE his reviews are relentlessly but intelligently scathing.
Glenn Beck likes argument, but has a deap-seated hatred for logic.
We could just throw up a monthly Fanshot?
NEEDS MORE FREEDOM!
by Scruffy Lefty on Sep 10, 2009 3:11 PM PDT up reply actions

by 


























