Above is a select group of quarterbacks ranked by expected points added per play. It's a nice mix of players at different points in their careers, with different levels of surrounding talent and different levels of prestige, but relatively similar performance levels. Plays by Troy Smith have been quite a bit more valuable than plays by Brett Favre, but otherwise, everyone is pretty close.
If you were to re-rank the above ten quarterbacks by surrounding talent, what would your list look like?
Will any of the above quarterbacks lead their team to a playoff berth in 2011, and who?