NFL Draft 2012: Scouting on Shea McClellin; College Football Links for Saturday
For your prospect of the day on this wonderful Saturday morning, I wanted to bring up a guy that I've been a little bit intrigued with, Boise State's Shea McClellin. He's intriguing because he's that mix of defensive end and linebacker with some length and versatility, and the Seahawks have shown interest in players like this and more specifically with those two attributes. He doesn't have elite speed or athleticism, but rather shows instincts and again, an ability to play several positions that make him an intriguing mid-round guy to keep an eye on. Several experts I respect talked about him recently as well, so I thought I'd point you to that.
Rob Rang wrote about him a few weeks back. Per Rang:
Listed by the Broncos at 6-3, 255 pounds, McClellin was moved around a great deal but saw the majority of his snaps at defensive end, where he's currently rated by NFLDraftScout.com as a fourth-round value. McClellin accepted the invitation to the Senior Bowl, anticipating he would remain at the position but perhaps see some time at linebacker. Instead, he has worked almost exclusively at linebacker, taking virtually every snap Wednesday on the weak side and proving his versatility and draft grade are perhaps significantly underrated.
"I didn't think I'd be playing pure linebacker here. ... I thought I was going to be doing a little bit of both," McClellin said. "But, it is kind of my choice, too, doing a lot of work at linebacker. I have a lot of film at defensive end and outside linebacker. They put me at weakside and I thought it would be a good idea just to show my skills in that area."
In that same article, Mike Singletary weighed in:
"Let me just say this, if [McClellin] wants to play D-line, he can play D-line. If he wants to play linebacker, he can play linebacker. He is the kind of guy that can fit either way.
"He's a guy that right now is about 255 pounds. He can pick up and go to 275 and go back to D-line or he can stay where he's at. He's got a lot of good stuff ahead of him because he's also a worker. You find a guy like him with his versatility and intangibles -- he's also a smart kid -- and he's going to be just fine at the next level."
Rang continues by talking about McClellin's switch from mostly-DE at BSU to playing mostly linebacker at the Senior Bowl.
Proving much more comfortable than expected considering his lack of experience at the position, McClellin showed good diagnosis skills, quickly attacking gaps in the running game. He took on blocks aggressively, using his long, strong arms to quickly disengage as well as the flexibility and awareness to keep his feet free from the mass of humanity surrounding him near the line of scrimmage. Though not allowed to take ball carriers to the ground during practice, McClellin closed quickly and wrapped up securely before releasing them to finish their runs. As impressive as McClellin was defending the run, it was his surprising agility and awareness in coverage that caught some by surprise.
Look - I don't really know what the Seahawks are looking for in their linebackers. Pete Carroll stressed the need for speed at the position in his offseason presser but it's pretty well known they value instincts and coverage ability in their linebackers as well. They also stress the importance of scheme versatility and an ability to get after the passer but also run with tight ends and running backs, so McClellin just intrigues me. He's also the kind of guy I could see just kicking ass and taking names on special teams, and I know the Seahawks place a bit of importance on that as well.
Jene Bremel - a writer for FootballGuys.com and the Rookie Scouting Porfolio - recently wrote on McClellin:
Tweeners that can play either 4-3 DE or 3-4 OLB are common. But the term tweener implies a pass rushing prospect, not necessarily a player who can drop into coverage well enough to have potential value as a 4-3 SLB or 3-4 LOLB. Cam Johnson, Melvin Ingram, Courtney Upshaw and Vinny Curry are all tweeners in that traditional sense but aren't guys that will be asked to do something other than rush the passer for more than a token snap here or there. A solid pass rushing prospect, McClellin backed up glimpses of all-around linebacker play on tape by flashing the ability to turn and run with backs and tight ends during practice this week. Such versatility can push an otherwise one-dimensional pass rushing prospect from the 5th or 6th round into the 3rd.
Anyway - these attributes remind me vaguely of K.J. Wright and we saw the Seahawks take him in the fourth round, then eventually insert him into the starting lineup, successfully, in year one. Check out some more on McClellin after the jump, and I've also included some college football links to read as well.
Big thanks toDraftBreakdown for the excellent scouting videos they put together - Aaron Aloysius, JMPasq,JPDraftJedi, TTN2810, MARI0clp and the whole DraftBreakdown crew.
_______________________________________________________________
Scout's Notes: Prospects at Each Position that I "Love" | Articles
In the Valentine's Day spirit, I wanted to return the "Scout's Notes" section of the site on a high note: prospects I "love".
Buyer Beware: First Round WRs are Risky Propositions | Articles
Some of the hottest topics of debate leading up to this year’s draft have revolved around wide receivers with the potential to be drafted in the first round. Is Justin Blackmon worthy of a top five pick? Will Kendall Wright go down as the best receiver in the class? Will Alshon Jeffery be able to stay (or get into) shape? Where does Malcom Floyd fit into the picture?
Tannehill out of boot, will re-schedule Pro Day - CBSSports.com
While Oklahoma State's Brandon Weeden and Michigan State's Kirk Cousins boosted their stock with strong efforts at the Senior Bowl, Texas A&M's Ryan Tannehill remains the most talented senior quarterback in the land and is likely to be the first one drafted.
Draft Breakdown — Closer Look: San Diego State RB Ronnie Hillman
Hillman is going to be a player that some teams will look back on and regret not drafting. The NFL Advisory Committee told him that he could be drafted as early as the third round, which seems fitting; however, I look at Hillman as one of the most skilled running backs going into the draft.
Lead NFL Draft analysts say Browns should go after RG3 - Mocking The Draft
Mike Mayock of NFL Network and Todd McShay of ESPN both held media conference calls this week and both said the Cleveland Browns need Robert Griffin III.
Senio Kelemete 2012 NFL Draft Scouting Report - Mocking The Draft
Agility: Senio Kelemete has quick feet, but needs to refine his footwork a bit at the next level. He shuffles side to side well and has pretty good range. I like his ability to get to the second level in the run game and quickly pick up blockers.
Brandon Weeden 2012 NFL Draft scouting report - Mocking The Draft
Accuracy: He is very good when he stays over his feet and has an efficient delivery that allows him to complete short passes at a high percentage. He has the arm strength to make all of the deep throws.
From Cam to RGIII, and the weird psychology of draft analysis | Shutdown Corner - Yahoo! Sports
If there's one undeniable fact people hopefully learned from Cam Newton's rookie season, it's that the NFL has morphed into something that will allow a quarterback who played nothing but two-digit spread offense in college to succeed wildly at the next level in a pretty big hurry. Newton's historic performances for the Carolina Panthers stood in especially sharp relief after a pre-draft process that had a lot of people picking him apart in ways that went beyond the football field.
Georgia TE Orson Charles: Aaron Hernandez part II? | National Football Post
Just how big of a mismatch piece can this guy be on an NFL offense?
Defensive prospects in need of a strong Combine | National Football Post
Who needs to make a big impression in Indy?
McShay: DE Quinton Coples could fall to Seahawks - Blog - MyNorthwest.com
The Seahawks have identified pass-rush as an area they'll look to improve, no surprise given that their 33 sacks last season put them in a tie for 19th in the NFL. ESPN draft analyst Todd McShay joined "The Kevin Calabro Show" this week and spoke extensively about one player that could help in that department, Quinton Coples.
22 comments
|
2 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Classic trade-off between instincts/football skill and pure athleticism. Opposite Curry, closer to Tatupu...
…high effort, intelligent, relentless, over-achiever. Hybrid player, no pure position – is this the kind of guy PC/JS likes? I don’t know.
ONLY IN SEATTLE:
By swaggering could I never thrive,
For the rain, it raineth every day.
if history is evidence
Yes, he fits the profile well. I like the Curry/Fatuous comparison, it seems to fit. I could see this player on our board on day 2
by GnarlyHawk on Feb 18, 2012 8:12 AM PST via mobile up reply actions
damn autocorrect, sorry Tats
Getting used to the new springboard tablet
by GnarlyHawk on Feb 18, 2012 8:13 AM PST via mobile up reply actions
The Hawks could do worse than looking at Shea.
I could see him staying at 255 and being a KJ Wright type guy or gaining 20 lbs and being a Clemons type guy. I wonder how much of his instinctual ability is artificially amplified after playing for Coach Pete for so long. Something to look out for with all the BSU defensive guys considering Coach Pete is one of the best schemers in College.
Some intriguing Saturday morning scouting.
Thanks, Mr. Kelly. I agree he should be a player on our radar.
A thought; his ability to stunt (sometimes late…by design?) in the VT video stuck out, as it’s something Raheem did a lot for us last year. The fact that he can turn and run (as said by Bremel, who I really like) makes me think he could fit as depth in that spot, among other roles.
by Charlie Todaro on Feb 18, 2012 9:57 AM PST reply actions 1 recs
In that game vs Georgia he seems like a really heady player...
In that game specifically, it never looks like he gives up the outside contain when that is his responsibility, but he inside stunt is pretty stellar as Charlie noted. He looks like the playmaker in Boise’s front 7, but without scouting all of his teammates, it is tough to know how much is his talent vs his opportunity – regardless, he still takes advantage of his opportunity.
Smashmouth is the new sexy!
So if we don't resign Leroy...
Think this guy could fill that role? Or would we need a more specialized 4-3 OLB?
I took Upshaw with our 1st round pick in the reddit.com mock draft, trying to decide if I should take a DE or another OLB in the later rounds. I am assuming we do not resign Leroy Hill
ihope we resign hill
hes still got some quicks, pop and cheap
So is Keuchly completely off the table from a Seahawk standpoint?
He’ll likely be on the board, and is the highest rated ILB according to CBS. Is he too slow, not athletic enough for PC/JS:
Most NFL-caliber college defenders average eight total tackles a game, counting assisted and solo stops, during their most productive season. In 2010, Kuechly (pronounced Keek-ly) averaged nearly 8.5 solo stops and more than 14 in total during his sophomore season to lead the nation in both categories. While statistics are considered meaningless, or even misleading, when scouting pro prospects, Kuechly’s productivity is simply an indicator of his relentless pursuit of the ball.
The 183 tackles with which he was credited in his consensus All-American and first-team All-ACC 2010 season also included 10 stops for loss and 1.5 sacks. The runner-up for the 2010 Butkus Award (nation’s top linebacker) also intercepted three passes, broke up three others and forced two fumbles during the year. His 2009 numbers may have been even more remarkable considering his status as a true freshman. The Freshman All-American and ACC Defensive Rookie of the Year racked up 158 tackles and 87 solo (both ranking second in the entire FBS), along with 13 stops for loss and four pass break-ups.
Kuechly will not wow scouts with exceptional athleticism test results at the Combine, but his production and football intelligence will endear him to 4-3 teams looking for a James Laurinaitis-like leader of a defense. Whether he leaves after his junior campaign or finishes out his eligibility, expect Kuechly to be a top 50 pick.
Read & React: Intelligent player who knows his keys and “feels” his way to the ball. Aggressiveness allows him to be fooled by those keys, like pulling guards, on misdirection and takes a false step forward on play action, but also recovers well and regularly sniffs out reverses and other trick plays to prevent big gains.
Run defense: Constantly around the ball, fights traffic easily and steps into gaps instead of waiting for the ballcarriers. Tracks the ball to either sideline but needs perfect angles to beat NFL tailbacks to perimeter. Anchors and can stick bigger backs with lowered pads. Doesn’t have elite size to stand up to NFL-caliber linemen, but regularly rips off blocks with strong hands and can make plays even if initially knocked backward.
Pass defense: Not an elite athlete. Covers some ground in pass coverage and gets good depth in his drop, taking correct angles to stay with tight ends and bigger slot receivers down the middle. Takes time to reach running backs going into the flat. Reliable tackler in the middle zone to prevent yards after the catch on crossing routes.
Tackling: Secure tackler by not a feared one — plays strong and finds a way to bring down ballcarriers. Drops his hips, keeps his head up to drag down ballcarriers. Makes running backs pay for going out of bounds with a strong shoulder. Occasionally tries to tackle high, allowing the ballcarrier to elude. Relies on hustle and angles, not straight-line speed, to make plays outside the box.
Pass Rush/Blitz: Didn’t blitz often and lacks great closing speed to reach the quarterback from the stack. Sure open-field tackler who doesn’t miss many once he’s in the backfield with excellent tackling technique.
Intangibles: Exceptional on-field hustle and instincts and off-field work ethic. Gained good weight and muscle since arriving at BC. Should garner top general and football character and intelligence grades. Serves as back-up long snapper.
1st: Tannehill/Brockers/DeCastro
2nd: David/Iloka/Martin
3rd: Russell Wilson/Irvin/Polk
i haven't watched tape, but... SOLD!
Smashmouth is the new sexy!
I hate myself for saying this, but drafting Keuchly would to me be almost a worst-case scenario.
"The time has come," the Walrus said, "to talk of many things."
Can you say why? I have a similar feeling, but LB is a need, and having an elite MLB would be something...but...
1st: Tannehill/Brockers/DeCastro
2nd: David/Iloka/Martin
3rd: Russell Wilson/Irvin/Polk
He seems more 'overachieving White guy' than he does 'next Ray Lewis'.
What do I know. But, I’d rather see them go LB in later rounds.
"The time has come," the Walrus said, "to talk of many things."
He's an absolute beast...
I would LOVE to add him. He fits right in with our defensive identity of physicality, he’s wicked smaht, and would anchor the entire D, the eye of an evolving storm of stunts, blitzes and general trickery.
He isn’t unathletic. He’s just not a ridiculous combine freak. HOWEVER, I heard some talk that he has been working hard on “combine football” to blow everyone away physically there in addition to his fantastic on field production.
He is NOT a “worst-case” scenario…. he is an instant impact player.
I've put away the whiskey and the chainsaw and gone responsible. I'd like to say "Danny Kelly made me do it!" but that would be a lie. I chose to shave, put on a suit and tie and pretend I'm more important than I really am...
by Tyler Jorgensen on Feb 20, 2012 3:05 PM PST up reply actions
At least concede the positional value is lower.
"The time has come," the Walrus said, "to talk of many things."
What do you mean?
That a MLB is less valuable than an OLB?!?
Perhaps. But that’s because people draft more on potential than performance when it comes to LB. Patrick Willis was drafted 11th, Jonathan Vilma 12th, Brian Urlacher 9th.
Obviously only a high end prospect should be taken that high, but I do believe that he is a high end prospect worthy of consideration, and again, I’m not so dialed into “positional value” or expectations of any kind. I say, “Can the guy make my team better, significantly so, the next 5 years?” If the answer is “YES!” then why say, "but he’s 5 (or 8 or 12 spots too high on our chart compared to anyone else’s.)
But he’s not going to fall past 15, regardless. He’s too good a MLB.
I've put away the whiskey and the chainsaw and gone responsible. I'd like to say "Danny Kelly made me do it!" but that would be a lie. I chose to shave, put on a suit and tie and pretend I'm more important than I really am...
by Tyler Jorgensen on Feb 20, 2012 9:08 PM PST up reply actions
(Listed those guys because they were high end ILB prospects)
There are a TON of OLB prospects and DE prospects taken that high that burnt/flamed out. There’s more risk/reward at the other positions vs. MLB.
I've put away the whiskey and the chainsaw and gone responsible. I'd like to say "Danny Kelly made me do it!" but that would be a lie. I chose to shave, put on a suit and tie and pretend I'm more important than I really am...
by Tyler Jorgensen on Feb 20, 2012 9:09 PM PST up reply actions
I just meant 4-3 linebacker, compared to D-line of secondary.
I’ll be honest I’m not really discriminating within linebacker positions. That’s for you pros.
"The time has come," the Walrus said, "to talk of many things."
Gotcha.
Well, typically the pass rushing slots are where “reaches” are found and the ILB tends to be a “safer” pick.
When I say pass rushing, I mean either DE in a 4-3 or OLB in a 3-4. The 3-4 DE and 4-3 MLB tend to go later, as they are considered more niche guys/role players/sub-elite.
Yet those guys are/can be key cogs on elite teams.
I don’t know. Bottom line, pick someone who will help us win…. that’s all any of us want.
I've put away the whiskey and the chainsaw and gone responsible. I'd like to say "Danny Kelly made me do it!" but that would be a lie. I chose to shave, put on a suit and tie and pretend I'm more important than I really am...
by Tyler Jorgensen on Feb 20, 2012 11:54 PM PST up reply actions
Absolutely.
If we draft him, I’ll be sad for ten seconds and then I’m on the bandwagon. I’ll gladly eat my hat for the next decade if he turns out to be a star.
"The time has come," the Walrus said, "to talk of many things."
Can you point me to a quick-and-dirty breakdown on Will vs. Sam prototypes?
"The time has come," the Walrus said, "to talk of many things."

by 
































