DK edit: Obviously it's early in the offseason and the roster will change before it's all said and done, but I thought this was an interesting look at the age & experience distribution for the 2012 Seahawks' team.
Pete Carroll and John Schneider have assembled a roster full of young, athletic, aggressive, and hungry (for success) football players. With so much youth, and so little experience, what can we expect in 2012? How close is the team to contending for a title?
Taking a look at the professional development and experience of each player may suggest how well the team will play in 2012.
This roster review was inspired by Kenneth Arthur’s post a while ago:
Only those players that I think will significantly impact the season will be included, a total of 45 players.* Each of them will receive one of the following tags:
Rookie – first year in the league
Freshman – player with little to no real game experience
Sophomore – a player that has seen a fair amount of real-game action, yet can be expected to improve with more practice and experience.
Junior – more game experience than a sophomore and further along in their professional development, but has yet to reach their prime.
Prime – a player at his peak.
Post-Prime – a player past his peak
*************
QB
Tarvaris Jackson - Prime
Matt Flynn – Sophomore
Russell Wilson – Rookie
RB
Marshawn Lynch - Prime
Robert Turbin – Rookie
Michael Robinson – Prime
Leon Washington – Prime
WR
Sidney Rice – Prime
Mike Williams – Prime
Ben Obomanu – Prime
Deon Butler - Junior
Doug Baldwin – Sophomore
Golden Tate – Sophomore
Kris Durham – Freshman
Ricardo Lockette – Freshman
TE
Zach Miller – Prime
Cameron Morrah – Sophomore
Anthony McCoy – Sophomore
OT
Russell Okung – Junior
James Carpenter – Sophomore
Paul McQuistin – Sophomore
Breno Giacomini - Sophomore
OG
John Moffitt – Sophomore
Deuce Lutui – Post-Prime
C
Max Unger – Junior
*************
DT
Brandon Mebane – Prime
Alan Branch – Prime
DE
Red Bryant – Prime
Chris Clemons - Prime
Jason Jones – Prime
Bruce Irvin – Rookie
LB
Leroy Hill - Prime
K.J. Wright – Sophomore
Bobby Wagner – Rookie
Malcolm Smith – Freshman
DB
Brandon Browner – Prime
Marcus Trufant – Post-Prime
Richard Sherman – Sophomore
Walter Thurmond – Sophomore
Byron Maxwell – Freshman
Jeremy Lane – Rookie
SS/FS
Earl Thomas – Junior
Kam Chancellor – Sophomore
Winston Guy - Rookie
Jeron Johnson - Sophomore
*************
Prime – 15/45 (33%)
Juniors – 4/45 (9%)
Sophomores – 14/45 (31%)
Freshmen – 4/45 (9%)
Rookies – 6/45 (13%)
Post-Prime – 2/45 (4%)
*************
1 - Only a third of the team are playing their best football, the implication being that they can get much better with more practice and experience
2 – there are very few, if any, aging veteran players in key roles. Lutui and Trufant probably won’t start, and may not impact the team very much one way or another
3 – The only unit made up entirely of players in their prime is the defensive front four. Every other unit contains a mix of young players and veterans
4 – The starting defensive back-field has only one player rated in his prime (Browner). A very young and upcoming group.
5 – The unit I have the least confidence in rating is the offensive line. I don’t think any of them are in their prime; my understanding is that it takes time and experience for a guard, tackle (and especially) a center to reach their full professional maturity.
6 – Presumably only six of the eight WRs will make the team. If Obo and BMW are taken off the list, Rice would be the only remaining player in his prime.
7 –Seattle will likely start one, and possibly two rookies (Wagner, Wilson), and likely count on rookies/freshmen for important starting/situational roles (Malcolm Smith at Will, Bruce Irvin as designated pass-rusher, Jeremy Lane as nickel-CB, Winston Guy in the Bigby role).
With such a young, inexperienced team, we are advised, as fans, to temper our expectations this coming season (even as I type these words I am already violating the recommendation).
*The players listed and the tags are my own subjective choices. Too many WRs, for instance; counting some rookies and not others (Guy and Lane, for instance). Obviously different choices would sway the analysis one way or another.
There are 10 Comments. Load Now.
Shortcuts to mastering the comment thread. Use wisely.
C - Next Comment
X - Mark as Read
R - Reply
Z - Mark Read & Next
Shift + C - Previous
Shift + A - Mark All Read
Comment Settings
Live comment alert: Hide it!
Comments for this post are closed.